A serious car-accident injury may create recommendations for follow-up visits, therapy, medication, diagnostic testing, procedures, equipment, home assistance, transportation, or other care. A present recommendation and a projected future cost answer different questions. The file should connect each estimate to a qualified source, the medical record, the stated assumptions, and the date the estimate was prepared.

A future-care estimate should identify the qualified source, recommendation date, item or service, expected frequency and duration, stated assumptions, cost source, uncertainty, and later update.

Begin with the actual clinical record

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services explains that individuals generally can request copies of medical and billing records. Its medical-records guidance identifies clinical notes, test results, billing information, and other records used to make decisions. Request the complete source record rather than relying only on a patient-portal summary or an estimate created from memory.

  • Provider and discipline, encounter date, reported history, examination, assessment, test or image reviewed, and recommendation
  • Service, item, medication, equipment, assistance, or modification; quantity; frequency; duration; start condition; end condition; and alternative
  • Restriction, dependency, reassessment date, contingency, probability language, missing information, and later change
  • Whether the source addresses treatment, cost, collision causation, prognosis, necessity, reasonableness, or none of those separate questions

Keep qualified opinion and arithmetic distinct

North Carolina Rule of Evidence 702 addresses testimony by a qualified expert and the reliability requirements stated in the rule. A spreadsheet can multiply units by a price, but that arithmetic does not establish the medical premise, duration, causation, or necessity. Identify who supplied each premise and retain the material the person reviewed.

Build a transparent cost-source table

  • Item or service, code or description, geographic area, provider or vendor, quote date, cash price, billed charge, allowed amount, paid amount, and patient responsibility
  • One-time, recurring, replacement, maintenance, training, travel, delivery, tax, professional, facility, or related cost kept in separate rows
  • Units per period, number of periods, base year, stated price trend or inflation assumption, discount assumption, present-value method, and person performing the calculation
  • Insurance, public benefit, contract, lien, reimbursement, authorization, deductible, policy, or eligibility issue recorded as uncertain unless established

Do not treat one bill as the future price

North Carolina Rule of Evidence 414 addresses evidence offered to prove past medical expenses and limits those expenses to amounts actually paid or necessary to satisfy the bills that have been incurred. Future-care analysis is a separate issue. The source, purpose, applicable evidence rules, and case facts determine how a particular estimate may be evaluated.

Version the estimate as care changes

Record a new version when a procedure occurs, a recommendation changes, recovery progresses, a complication appears, an item is no longer needed, a new quote arrives, or coverage information changes. Preserve the earlier version and explain the reason for the revision. Do not silently replace an estimate or present a contingent option as a certain future event.

The related guide to building a hospital-to-home record after a serious car-accident injury addresses medications, equipment, appointments, and assistance during the initial transition. This page owns the separate source-and-assumption audit for projected care.

Rosensteel Fleishman Car Accident & Injury Lawyers provides information about North Carolina car-accident claims involving serious injuries and future-care evidence. Qualified medical and financial analysis, current records, and individual facts control any projection.

Sources