A consultation is more useful when the client brings a short chronology and asks the same core questions of each candidate. The goal is not to obtain a confident prediction from limited facts. It is to understand the analysis, proposed work, relationship, and cost.

A useful interview question reveals responsibility, evidence, uncertainty, cost, or client authority.

Licensure and relevant work

  • Are you active and eligible to practice in North Carolina?
  • Which event, evidence, defense, insurance, or procedural issues in my matter have you handled before?
  • Who would be the responsible lawyer and who else would work on the file?
  • Does your current workload allow the urgent work this matter requires?

The North Carolina State Bar public guidance recommends reviewing active licensure, relevant experience and knowledge, disciplinary record, malpractice insurance, reputation, temperament, fees, and expenses.

Initial assessment and uncertainty

  • What legal duty and claim type may apply?
  • Which facts currently support and undermine liability, causation, and damages?
  • What defenses, parties, coverage, or procedural issues require investigation?
  • Which record or event is most likely to change the current assessment?

Evidence and deadlines

  • What evidence may disappear, and who will preserve it?
  • Which medical, incident, employment, insurance, contract, or electronic records are needed?
  • What limitation, notice, filing, response, or court date applies?
  • What should I keep, avoid altering, or refrain from posting?

Scope and case plan

  • Does the engagement include only negotiation or also filing, discovery, mediation, trial, and appeal?
  • Which related claims or proceedings are excluded?
  • What are the first five tasks and the first decision point?
  • What work and information remain the client’s responsibility?

Communication and client decisions

State Bar Rule 1.4 addresses consultation, status, reasonable requests, and explanation for informed decisions. Ask who communicates routine and urgent matters, how often status is reviewed, and how offers or changes in assessment are presented.

  • Which decisions belong to me, and which means are ordinarily handled by counsel?
  • How are disagreements about strategy, expense, or timing addressed?
  • Will I receive copies of pleadings, discovery, material correspondence, offers, and orders?
  • How can I verify the current task, deadline, and person responsible?

Fees, expenses, and net proceeds

Rule 1.5 governs fee and expense issues, including contingent-fee writings. Ask for a calculation under several scenarios.

  • How is the fee calculated before filing, after filing, at trial, on appeal, or if the relationship ends?
  • Which expenses may be incurred, who approves and advances them, and who bears them if there is no recovery?
  • How are medical balances, health-plan or government repayment, and other deductions handled?
  • When and how will I receive a written settlement statement showing gross payment and net proceeds?

Settlement and litigation

  • How will you evaluate liability, medical causation, damages, coverage, defenses, and collectability?
  • How will complete release terms and alternatives be explained?
  • What discovery, depositions, experts, motions, mediation, and trial work may be required?
  • Which developments would make settlement, filing, or trial more or less appropriate?

Conflicts, confidentiality, and transition

  • Who is the client, and whose interests or information could create a conflict?
  • Who may receive information or participate in meetings?
  • What happens if the firm cannot continue or I change counsel?
  • How will the file, deadlines, physical evidence, fees, expenses, and court responsibilities transfer?

End with a written first-month plan

If an engagement begins, record the assigned people, client tasks, firm tasks, evidence-preservation actions, records requests, insurance notices, deadlines, next meeting, and conditions that may alter the plan. If no engagement begins, obtain confirmation and continue protecting evidence and time limits.

The related change-of-counsel guide explains the file, deadline, fee, court, and communication issues that matter if representation later transitions.

Rosensteel Fleishman Car Accident & Injury Lawyers provides information about questions for a North Carolina personal-injury consultation. Specific answers make it easier to compare the proposed relationship without unsupported claims.

Sources