After an accident, it is common for people to feel unsure about what comes next, especially when back pain begins to interfere with daily life. Even a minor collision can cause physical issues that do not show up right away. This can leave someone wondering how serious the injury might be or how they will […]
Expert Opinion on Proximate Cause
Although expert testimony can touch on ultimate issues of fact, see N.C. Gen. Stat. § 8C-1, Rule 704, experts cannot testify on ultimate issues of law:
[A]n expert may not testify that a particular legal conclusion or standard has or has not been met, at least where the standard is a legal term of art which carries a specific meaning not readily apparent to the witness.
State v. White, 340 N.C. 264, 294, 457 S.E.2d 841, 859 (1995). The term “proximate cause” is a legal term of art, and thus is an ultimate issue of law. See State v. Ledford, 315 N.C. 599, 340 S.E.2d 309 (1986) (holding that it was error to allow an expert to testify that the injuries suffered by the victim were the “proximate cause” of her death); State v. Rose, 323 N.C. 455, 459, 373 S.E.2d 426, 429 (1988) (medical expert could not testify that a defendant did or did not "premeditate and deliberate", testimony embraced precise legal terms, definitions of which are not readily apparent to medical experts); State v. Weeks, 322 N.C. 152, 165-67, 367 S.E.2d 895, 903-04 (1988)(trial court did not err by refusing to admit testimony of medical experts that the defendant did not act in a "cool state of blood," testimony embraced precise legal terms, definitions of which are not readily apparent to medical experts); State v. O'Hanlan, 153 N.C. App. 546, 557, 570 S.E.2d 751, 758 (2002) (doctor's opinion that the victim was kidnapped and raped was improper); State v. Galloway, 304 N.C. 485, 489, 284 S.E.2d 509, 512 (1981) (medical expert may not testify that the defendant raped the prosecuting witness).
Additional Law Articles Articles
How a Charlotte Workers Compensation Law Firm for Paralysis Cases Guides Families Through Complex Claims
Families dealing with paralysis after a work accident often find themselves overwhelmed by sudden changes in daily routines, medical needs, and financial pressures. It can feel like everything happens at once, and there is not always a clear place to turn for guidance. Many people start searching for support while trying to understand their rights, […]
Understanding Your Options with a Motorcycle Accident Legal Rights Attorney in NC
Recovering from a motorcycle accident is not only physically draining, it can leave you emotionally scattered and unsure of where to turn next. You might be juggling hospital bills, insurance paperwork, time off work, and lingering pain, all while wondering whether your legal rights are being protected. This kind of stress is more than most […]
How an Injury Compensation Lawyer in Charlotte Helps Accident Victims
Car accidents and unexpected injuries can leave people feeling overwhelmed and unsure of what steps to take next. The physical pain is often just one piece of the challenge. Victims may find themselves dealing with medical bills, lost time at work, and pressure from insurance companies. In these moments, having the right guidance matters. That […]
